THE CORE

Fruits & Votes is the Web-log of Matthew S. Shugart ("MSS"), Professor of Political Science, University of California, Davis.

Perspectives on electoral systems, constitutional design, and policy around the world, based primarily on my research interests.

Also experiences with growing many varieties of fruit (always organic) and other personal interests. Please see the Mission Statement for more. (There is also an explanation of the banner.)

Other "planters" have been invited to contribute. Please check the "Planted by" line to see the author of the post you are reading.

Join the conversation. Comments are always open. Except, that is, when Word Press mysteriously shuts them down, which happens with distressing frequency.

Core principles:

Henry Droop on the "moderate non-partisan section"

Madison on "dangers from abroad" and "the fetters... on liberty"

The Head Orchardist's other sites:

PRESERVED FRUIT
orchard blocks
  • All
  • FRUITS
  • VOTES
  • wide open spaces
  • 18 May 2007

    Planted by MSS
    Planted in: Judaism

    Yesterday, 29 Iyar, Day 44 of the Omer and thus six days from Shavuot, I emerged from the mikveh a member of the People Israel. For some of you reading this, the only surprise is that I was not already a Jew. Others may not even care; you come here, after all, for the Fruits and the Votes and not for “religion.” Fair enough. I won’t tell my life story here, or even delve much into the reasons for taking such a momentous and personal step. My wife of 15 years is a Jew and I have identified with the Jewish People for some time. Now the Jewish People formally identify with me, as well. And Judaism is a communal religion (and much, much more than a religion) and thus a public declaration is part of the process. Or so it should be. And what better public forum than my blog?

    An interesting aspect of my profession is the relative lack of interest among its practitioners in the religious, the spiritual, in God. I know significant numbers of Jews in the profession in the sense of their having Jewish heritage, but very few who are, at least to my knowledge, “observant” in any way. I can also think of very few colleagues who are active or observant in any faith tradition–again, to my knowledge. (Maybe there are many whose religious activity is simply unknown to me.) I certainly do know a few who are devout Christians as well as scholars, but they are indeed few. I see no contradiction in being religiously observant and being a good scientist, political or otherwise. Yet my sense is that my profession–and I am speaking only of political science here–is overwhelmingly atheist or agnostic. I won’t attempt to explain why that might be so. It is an interesting question, but I will leave that for another day (and most likely another forum, unless readers care to discuss it in the comments). From my perspective, religion and science (political or otherwise) are separate pursuits, and one does not validate or invalidate the other. Thus while keeping them separate certainly makes for good secular professional ethics, being serious about one should not prevent one from being equally serious about the other. And yet the most serious scholars seem rarely to be serious about belief in a higher Source. It is my personal opinion that Judaism–especially its progressive streams–is more consistent with science than any other faith tradition, but saying so is not an attempt to spark a debate. It is just a personal statement. Your mileage may vary, and rest assured that I have no intention of “converting” this blog or its readers just because the blogger has converted.

    The following words, from a liberal Jewish prayer book, capture about as well as any could my reason for making this transformation (not that anyone does, or should, do this for “reason” alone; one must have–and I do have–a deep emotional connection):

    I am a Jew because my faith demands no abdication of the mind.

    I am a Jew because my faith demands all the devotion of my heart.

    I am a Jew because wherever there is suffering, the Jew weeps.

    I am a Jew because wherever there is despair, the Jew hopes.

    I am a Jew because the message of our faith is the oldest and the newest.

    I am a Jew because the promise of our faith is a universal promise.

    I am a Jew because for the Jew, the world is not completed; people must complete it.

    I am a Jew because for the Jew, humanity is not fully created; people must complete it.

    I am a Jew because the faith of the people Israel places humanity above nations, above Judaism itself.

    I am a Jew because the faith of the people Israel places above humanity, image of the divine, the Oneness of God.

    I will be known among the People Israel as Matityahu ben Avraham v’ Sarah.

    One of my favorite biblical quotes–because of not only its message, but also its fruit-growing allusions–concerns the Messianic era. The very concept is difficult for some, so it is worth prefacing with a note that the Messianic era is understood by Jews (at least liberal/progressive Jews) as the days we ourselves help bring along, not by faith, but by what we observe ( “let them [the commandments/ mitzvot] be a symbol between your eyes”) and what we do ( “bind them as a sign upon your hand”)–that is, what we observe about the world around us and what actions we take to make it better. It may be a stretch–perhaps a very big stretch–but my “observance” of the rules of organic agriculture (and my evolving interest in Eco-Kashrut), my academic efforts to understand better how democracy works (and why it too often does not), and my advocacy of electoral reform as a means to enhance the voice of those who are not otherwise powerful are among my tiny and insignificant contributions to what Jews refer to as Tikkun Olam (repairing the world). That is, while I have much more to do, now that I have accepted the responsibilities of the Covenant, in many ways, this is a “confirmation” of what I have been striving for in my secular life for some time. We all have our work cut out for ourselves, but one day:

    … all shall sit under their vine and under their fig tree, and none shall make them afraid… (Micah 4:4).

    Ken yehi ratson.

    Propagation: Seeds & scions (3)


    3 ideas sprouting »

    1. Congratulations! Actually, a few years ago, I almost chose that path myself (I ended up choosing Catholicism instead), so I’m deeply respectful of people who seek out that kind of journey. Mozel tav!

      Seed planted by Miguel Centellas — 18 May 2007 @ 20:57

    2. As a person who converted to Catholicism as well about 10 years ago, congratulations!

      Seed planted by Jack Lazorko — 21 May 2007 @ 12:28

    3. Mazal tov! May I take this opportunity to thank you for all I’ve learned from you, you’ve certainly fulfilled the mitzvah of teaching.

      While I can’t speak for the field of political science, there are many Jews who are active in both religion and science. The tradition of Torah im derech eretz goes back at least to the Rambam, if not earlier. (I’m sure the Sanhedrin could have used a consultant on voting systems, no?)

      Seed planted by Vasi — 28 June 2007 @ 06:09

    RSS feed for comments on this post.

    TrackBacks

    To graft a scion to this planting, please use the following URL:
    http://fruitsandvotes.com/blog/wp-trackback.php?p=1240
    (Non-MT bloggers click here to send pings.)

    Grafted scions that are not compatible with this planting's stock will die or be pruned out by the Orchardist.

    About the comment form

    Please note that the name you enter below and the first several words of your comment will appear on the right sidebar of the blog's front page, under "Propagation." New propagators might want to look at the comment policy.

    Please do not enter long URLs into the seedbed. Either mark them up using html hyperlinks or convert them to a "tiny URL." Thank you!

    Seedbed

    The soil is ready for planting:

    `

    FRUIT FEEDS
    PROPAGATION
    Recent comments.

  • Is MMP in Ireland’s future? (7)
    • Wilf Day: Ireland’s Constitutional Convention is a very interesting model of an electoral reform process. It includes 66 randomly selected...
    • MSS: Yes, electoral-syste m change would require a constitutional amendment, which is why it is a topic of the Constitutional Convention. The...
    • Alan: I expect the sixth and last senate place to be decided by very small margins in a number of states. Voting below the line will have more than...
    • Tom Round: Sorry, I should clarify: A legal change to an explicit party list system would indeed require a referendum to amend the Constituti...
    • JD: Tom: I think the Irish probably DO like getting a choice among different candidates of the same party. Whether their leaders like offering that...
  • Do UK elections now allow fusion candidacies? (10)
    • Chris: UKIP’s candidates for Parliament and MEP do indeed seem to need National Executive Committee Approval before being placed on the...
    • Chris: I think the key thing in being a Conservative-UK IP candidate might not be in having both of their emblems, but in not having an UKIP...
    • MSS: Here is the text (see Jaffr’s link): After paragraph (2A) insert— “(2AA)If a candidate who is the subject of an authorisation by...
    • MSS: Let me call attention here to Jaffr. at comment #1, who notes the amendment to the ballot law was passed earlier in 2013. (This comment was...
    • Tom Round: > “would officially be Conservative-Li beral on the ballot” The UK only adopted ballot labels in the early 1970s, and...
    • DC: The Co-operative Party’s candidates run as “Labour & CooperativeR 21; (it describes itself as a sister party to Labour)....
  • Distortions of the US House: It’s not how the districts are drawn, but that there are (single-seat) districts (30)
    • Ed: This is another article where the writer attempted to draw non-partisan districts, using a set of criteria an independent commission could...
  • Does STV have anything to do with absence of “free votes” in Ireland? (16)
    • MSS: I was sort of hoping this thread would be about free votes and STV’s possible role in them, but whatever… Uruguay has primary...
    • JD: Tom: There is far more variety than that. You have for example the compulsory primaries in Argentina, parties having primaries closed to party...
  • CROSS-POLLINATION

    FRUITS

    morn_blms_corralito.jpg

    The Fruit Blog (Fruit & fruit breeding)
    Daley's Fruit Tree Blog
    Orchards Forever
    The Orchard Keeper
    The Ethicurean
    The Jew and the Carrot
    Small farms ("real people & real food")
    Life begins at 30 (Farmers markets, etc.)
    Banana
    Festival of Trees
    Rare Fruit News Online
    Cloudforest Cafe


    VOTES

    bulgaria_protest copy

    Comparative democracy

    Psephos (Adam Carr's data archive)
    Electoral Panorama
    World Elections
    African Elections Database
    M. Herrera's Electoral Calendar
    Electoral Geography (Data archive)
    Michael Gallagher's data archive
    Election Finance (Blog, data archive)
    IFES
    Election Law (Rick Hasen)
    VoteLaw (Edward Still)
    Ballot Access News

    Electoral and Political Reform

    The FairVote Blog (US)
    Make my vote count (UK)
    Wilf Day (Canada)
    democraticSPACE (Canada)
    Citizens Assembly Blog (dormant)


    POLITOLOGY

    Blogs of political analysis

    PoliBlog
    Arms and Influence (dormant)
    Outside the Beltway
    Political Science Weblog (abstracts)
    Ideological Cartography (Adam Bonica)
    Frontloading HQ (Josh Putnam)
    FiveThirtyEight
    Vote View (Keith Poole)
    The Monkey Cage
    A Plain Blog About Politics (Jonathan Bernstein)
    Political Arithmetik (dormant)
    Polls & Votes
    Pollster.com
    Polysigh
    Reflective Pundit
    Rustbelt Intellectual
    Simon Jackman
    The semi-presidential one
    Josep Colomer
    Chapel Hill Treehouse (dormant)
    Political Behavior (dormant)
    Dart-Throwing Chimp
    Countries at the Crossroads (Freedom House blog)
    Jacob T. Levy

    REGIONAL ANALYSIS

    Canada

    The Mace
    ThreeHundredEight
    Crawl Across the Ocean
    Idealistic Pragmatist

    Europe

    Centre for European Politics
    Dr Sean's Diary
    A Fistful of Euros
    Political Reform (Ireland)
    UK Polling Report
    British Politics & Policy (LSE)

    Latin America

    Bloggings by boz
    Two Weeks Notice

    S.W. Asia & E. Mediterranean & N. Africa

    Informed Comment Global Affairs
    Lisa Goldman
    Michael J. Totten
    Yaacov Lozowick
    Marc Lynch (@FP)
    Ahwa Talk

    Africa

    La Constitution en Afrique

    E. Asia

    Frozen Garlic (Taiwan elections)

    New Zealand

    Kiwiblog
    No Right Turn

    OTHER SOCIAL SCIENCE BLOGS

    Crooked Timber
    Statistical Modeling
    Social Science Statistics
    Cold Spring Shops
    Marginal Revolution
    Brad DeLong
    Greg Mankiw

    SUN & MOON

    CURRENT MOON

    NEWS

    ABC

    BBC

    CBC

    Democracy Now!

    Deutsche Welle

    El Tiempo

    Guardian

    Haaretz

    Hindustan Times

    The Independent

    Irish Times

    NZ Stuff

    RFE/RL

    ORGANIZATIONS

    About/disclaimer

    California Rare Fruit Growers

    Center for Voting and Democracy

    Californians for Electoral Reform

    Society for American Baseball Research

    Link TV

    SCION EXCHANGE

    HARVESTS
    ORCHARD SERVICES

    Powered by WordPress