THE CORE

Fruits & Votes is the Web-log of Matthew S. Shugart ("MSS"), Professor of Political Science, University of California, Davis.

Perspectives on electoral systems, constitutional design, and policy around the world, based primarily on my research interests.

Also experiences with growing many varieties of fruit (always organic) and other personal interests. Please see the Mission Statement for more. (There is also an explanation of the banner.)

Other "planters" have been invited to contribute. Please check the "Planted by" line to see the author of the post you are reading.

Join the conversation. Comments are always open. Except, that is, when Word Press mysteriously shuts them down, which happens with distressing frequency.

Core principles:

Henry Droop on the "moderate non-partisan section"

Madison on "dangers from abroad" and "the fetters... on liberty"

The Head Orchardist's other sites:

PRESERVED FRUIT
orchard blocks
  • All
  • FRUITS
  • VOTES
  • wide open spaces
  • 12 January 2006

    Planted by MSS
    Planted in: ELECTORAL SYSTEMS & REFORM

    That tooting sound you are hearing is simply my own horn. Tipped off by a colleague, I found that the article that presents the theory of how different electoral systems affect the “personal vote” is the no. 1 “hottest” article at the journal, Electoral Studies. Not bad for having been published more than a decade ago!

    TOP25 articles within the journal:
    Electoral Studies

      Incentives to Cultivate a Personal Vote: a Rank Ordering of Electoral Formulas • Article
      Electoral Studies, Volume 14, Issue 4, 1 December 1995, Pages 417-439
      Carey, J.M.; Shugart, M.S.

    The full list of the 25 hottest is mostly articles from 2005 or 2004, and only two others as old as 1999.

    The first F&V discussion of the personal vote was a post on Palestinian candidate nominations.

    Core expectations* derived from this article were tested and confirmed in an article I co-authored in the American Journal of Political Science, April, 2004. (One could ask what took me so long, but I hope one doesn’t.) Continuing analysis of these matters is the topic of a National Science Foundation grant I am working on now.

    *That personal vote-earning attributes of legislators–specifically, district nativity, and prior electoral experience (municipal, provincial, etc.)–would be more prevalent as district magnitue increases in open-list systems and as magnitude decreases in closed-list systems (see graph of predicted values based on data from several European countries). The logic is that high-magnitude open-list systems are more competitive, putting candidates with local connections that they can advertise at an increasing advantage, whereas in closed lists, only at low magnitudes can parties gain advantages over others by placing locally connected candidates on the list. Ongoing research is looking at other types of electoral systems besides purely open or closed lists, at losing candidates, and at specific ranks on lists. It will keep me (and co-authors and grad students–busy for a while. It’s good to know, from the Electoral Studies download evidence, that others find this interesting!

    Propagation: Seeds & scions (6)


    The Democratic Piece grafted Repairing Iraq’s party system
    Fruits and Votes grafted Israel: Party-list formation updates

    6 ideas sprouting »

    1. Well, apart from Seats and Votes, I think that the personal vote piece is probably the piece of yours that I have cited the most. Of course, given that I write on Colombia, there is a certain logic to that…

      Seed planted by Steven Taylor — 12 January 2006 @ 11:25

    2. Indeed there is, and thanks Steven. I suppose that article is one of my personal (no pun intended) favorites from The Collected Works.

      Seed planted by Professor Matthew Søberg Shugart — 12 January 2006 @ 12:19

    3. Israel: Party-list formation updates

      Meanwhile, with Russian immigrants a large enough bloc of voters to swing up to 15 seats in the 120-seat Knesset, several parties are making an effort to appeal to this electorate by placing Russians in electable list ranks–annother example of parties using the ‘personal vote‘ of specific candidates as a way to attract votes even in a system where the only vote choice a voter gets is a party slate (and even in a very high-magnitude closed-list system). the Likud is banking on having two well-known Russian candidates in realistic spots on the party list: Natan Sharansky at number 10 and Yuli Edelstein at number 15.

      Scion grafted by Fruits and Votes — 26 January 2006 @ 11:27

    4. Well, just over a year later, and it has slipped to no. 2. Going on a dozen years since publication. I’ll take that ranking. No. 1 (B. Geys, “Explaining voter turnout”) was published in December, 2006, and one of the only two other articles in the journal’s top 10 to have been published before 2004 is also by yours truly.

      Of course, in this business, it’s always, what you have done lately…?

      Seed planted by MSS — 15 July 2007 @ 22:29

    5. Did it pass the quota of 3.846% on personal votes alone, or was it bumped over the line by surplus votes from the Shugart Party ticket as a whole?

      Seed planted by Tom Round — 16 July 2007 @ 22:45

    6. Repairing Iraq’s party system

      Luminaries from Lipset to Lijphart have taught that stable democratic politics are about more than race, religion or language. The challenge is to get Iraqi elites talking about more than sectarian interest. What candidates need are incentives to cultivate a personal vote.

      Scion grafted by The Democratic Piece — 17 April 2008 @ 15:43

    RSS feed for comments on this post.

    TrackBacks

    To graft a scion to this planting, please use the following URL:
    http://fruitsandvotes.com/blog/wp-trackback.php?p=474
    (Non-MT bloggers click here to send pings.)

    Grafted scions that are not compatible with this planting's stock will die or be pruned out by the Orchardist.

    About the comment form

    Please note that the name you enter below and the first several words of your comment will appear on the right sidebar of the blog's front page, under "Propagation." New propagators might want to look at the comment policy.

    Please do not enter long URLs into the seedbed. Either mark them up using html hyperlinks or convert them to a "tiny URL." Thank you!

    Seedbed

    The soil is ready for planting:

    `

    FRUIT FEEDS
    PROPAGATION
    Recent comments.

  • Is MMP in Ireland’s future? (21)
    • Tom Round: MSS @19: I’d semi-agree that party-list legislators are still “elected& #8221; (at least when the lists are published in...
    • Derek: Actually, the proposal I’m considering is a system where all candidates must run for many district seats and the number of seats...
    • MSS: I would completely reject Ed’s notion that members elected on party lists (closed) are “appointe d” instead of elected....
    • MSS: Interesting on attitudes towards STV variants, Tom! As for Hungary, it is not, and never was, MMP. But the system was indeed adopted before...
    • JD: How about the following MMP variant: both constituency and party-list votes are ranked. The constituency contest happens under AV. The...
    • Tom Round: (MSS @9) “To be clear, no specific legal threshold, or any threshold at all, is a defining feature of MMP” True. However,...
    • Mark Roth: @ JD, I stand corrected. @Derek, I believe that someone proposed something similarish for Canada right after the last federal election....
    • Derek: I’ve always thought of a different type of MMP system. The % for the winning party determines the number of seats chosen proportiona...
    • Suaprazzodi: Will Ireland embrace a one vote or two vote MMP system? Will it use FPTP in conjunction with a closed party list corrective element...
    • JD: Mark: If I’m not mistaken, neither Bolivia nor Lesotho (both MMP users) have thresholds.
    • Ed: I had a somewhat similar intellectual journey to Tom Round, in that MMP was beguiling at first until you got into the details. For me the deal...
    • Mark Roth: Just to be argumentative,a nd with no offense meant: 1) As far as I know, every system that uses MMP does have some sort of threshold in...
    • MSS: To be clear, no specific legal threshold, or any threshold at all, is a defining feature of MMP. Technically, neither are single-seat...
  • Pakistan general election 2013 (2)
    • MSS: The bandwagoning is taking place now. “PML-N gets majority after 18 Independents join party” (20 May). “43 newly elected...
  • CROSS-POLLINATION

    FRUITS

    morn_blms_corralito.jpg

    The Fruit Blog (Fruit & fruit breeding)
    Daley's Fruit Tree Blog
    Orchards Forever
    The Orchard Keeper
    The Ethicurean
    The Jew and the Carrot
    Small farms ("real people & real food")
    Life begins at 30 (Farmers markets, etc.)
    Banana
    Festival of Trees
    Rare Fruit News Online
    Cloudforest Cafe


    VOTES

    bulgaria_protest copy

    Comparative democracy

    Psephos (Adam Carr's data archive)
    Electoral Panorama
    World Elections
    African Elections Database
    M. Herrera's Electoral Calendar
    Electoral Geography (Data archive)
    Michael Gallagher's data archive
    Election Finance (Blog, data archive)
    IFES
    Election Law (Rick Hasen)
    VoteLaw (Edward Still)
    Ballot Access News

    Electoral and Political Reform

    The FairVote Blog (US)
    Make my vote count (UK)
    Wilf Day (Canada)
    democraticSPACE (Canada)
    Citizens Assembly Blog (dormant)


    POLITOLOGY

    Blogs of political analysis

    PoliBlog
    Arms and Influence (dormant)
    Outside the Beltway
    Political Science Weblog (abstracts)
    Ideological Cartography (Adam Bonica)
    Frontloading HQ (Josh Putnam)
    FiveThirtyEight
    Vote View (Keith Poole)
    The Monkey Cage
    A Plain Blog About Politics (Jonathan Bernstein)
    Political Arithmetik (dormant)
    Polls & Votes
    Pollster.com
    Polysigh
    Reflective Pundit
    Rustbelt Intellectual
    Simon Jackman
    The semi-presidential one
    Josep Colomer
    Chapel Hill Treehouse (dormant)
    Political Behavior (dormant)
    Dart-Throwing Chimp
    Countries at the Crossroads (Freedom House blog)
    Jacob T. Levy

    REGIONAL ANALYSIS

    Canada

    The Mace
    ThreeHundredEight
    Crawl Across the Ocean
    Idealistic Pragmatist

    Europe

    Centre for European Politics
    Dr Sean's Diary
    A Fistful of Euros
    Political Reform (Ireland)
    UK Polling Report
    British Politics & Policy (LSE)

    Latin America

    Bloggings by boz
    Two Weeks Notice

    S.W. Asia & E. Mediterranean & N. Africa

    Informed Comment Global Affairs
    Lisa Goldman
    Michael J. Totten
    Yaacov Lozowick
    Marc Lynch (@FP)
    Ahwa Talk

    Africa

    La Constitution en Afrique

    E. Asia

    Frozen Garlic (Taiwan elections)

    New Zealand

    Kiwiblog
    No Right Turn

    OTHER SOCIAL SCIENCE BLOGS

    Crooked Timber
    Statistical Modeling
    Social Science Statistics
    Cold Spring Shops
    Marginal Revolution
    Brad DeLong
    Greg Mankiw

    SUN & MOON

    CURRENT MOON

    NEWS

    ABC

    BBC

    CBC

    Democracy Now!

    Deutsche Welle

    El Tiempo

    Guardian

    Haaretz

    Hindustan Times

    The Independent

    Irish Times

    NZ Stuff

    RFE/RL

    ORGANIZATIONS

    About/disclaimer

    California Rare Fruit Growers

    Center for Voting and Democracy

    Californians for Electoral Reform

    Society for American Baseball Research

    Link TV

    SCION EXCHANGE

    HARVESTS
    ORCHARD SERVICES

    Powered by WordPress